As we reached the end of the 2026 season, we brought demolition to an end and began the good work of rebuilding this historic Troy beauty. Slowly but surely, we are making our way toward the completion of the project. After months of paperwork, design, more paperwork, demolition, more freaking paperwork, and, let’s not forget, yet more paperwork, we are finally starting the real build of the project.
Let’s look back on our journey so far. Here is how it started…









The first real work of our project was to take away the old to make room for the new. The demolition was extensive. We removed about two-thirds of all the building materials on site. First, we removed all the left-behind junk, kitchens, bathrooms, plaster walls, ceilings, and asbestos. We did this to see “the bones,” what the architect would call the structural members. Seeing how the building carries its own weight is critical to understanding what needs fixing, what’s worth reusing, and how to integrate the new addition into the building.
One of the most important ways to avoid the ridiculous contingency reserve that most historic projects require is to uncover as many issues as possible before fully pricing the job. When a good contractor comes to price a job, the more things that are hidden, the more the estimated price is padded “just in case,” to protect the contractor from getting stuck holding the bag for all the unknown issues.









The second phase of demolition focused on removing a number of internal brick chimneys and the entire original rear wall of the building. Since a wood-frame addition was added to the back of the building at some point, the original rear wall seemed like an internal wall at first. Removing the back wall was no small feat since all the floor joists tied into it.
Since we were adding a lot of square footage to the building, we wanted to make sure that the old rear wall did not break up our apartment spaces. Similarly, the old chimneys were all taking up extremely valuable square footage. Leaving the chimneys in would save us a few bucks, but the design and layout for two-thirds of the apartments would have to be made worse only to bury a bunch of old, dilapidated brickwork inside the walls. So, once all of the internal shoring was up and the brick wall was removed, it was time for phase three.









The third phase of the demolition consisted of taking down the tin-clad wood-frame addition, the two-story deck, the terracotta extension, and the carriage house. Since we are in a historic district, we saved a significant number of bricks so that the new structure can be built using the original bricks.
A building likely from the 1830s, in the heart of a city that was a thriving industrial powerhouse for over 150 years, had gone through many owners, each with their own use. While little record remains of what the commercial space was used for during the early 19th century, at the turn of the 20th century, the commercial space was used as a jewelry store, then a candy store, a grocer, and finally a hair salon. That’s a lot of different uses with vastly different requirements, each layered on top of the last. The time had come to remove nearly everything and start anew.









The fourth phase consisted of demolishing the foundation of the terracotta structure and digging the hole and pouring the foundation for the new addition to the main building. To keep costs under control, it made more sense to bring in big machines than to pay the high cost of digging everything by hand, especially since we already had a very large opening in the rear wall.
Part of our new design is to increase the size of the carriage house. Like the back wall of the main building, if we had “kept” the rear wall of the carriage house, it would have become an interior wall, a clunky obstacle that everything would have to be designed around. Instead, we decided to remove it, which, along with the need to bring in digging machines, made the decision all that much easier. When we are done, everything will be reconstructed using the original brick to preserve the historic character of the structure.






It is now two years since we became owners of this property, and things are finally starting to take shape. The hard part about this business is trusting a process where you spend 30% of your money and 50% of the project’s timeline feeling like you are going in reverse. If you don’t trust the process or have patience, this would be a nightmare. Feeling comfortable with the uncertainty, the ever-changing execution path, and the fact that progress often has no real visible consequence are all critical to successfully managing the construction process.
We could have chosen to do a lot less within the scope of this project, but the realities of real estate are simple: pay less upfront or pay more in the long term. For most, though, the “less upfront” comes across as “more upfront.” Sure, we could have reduced the scope of our renovation, but in the long term, the issues we were too cheap to address upfront would eventually come back to bite us with much higher expenses. Over the long term, it is the repairs and maintenance that really eat into your profitability. So the real question is, are you calculating your profitability based on the cash flow generated when the project is complete, or are you including the long-term cost of ownership?
Real estate is a game of patience and optimizing operating expenses. Focus on both the cost of the project and the cost of ownership over a ten-year period to figure out what will look cheap today but cost an arm and a leg in the future. That is the path I have chosen as a developer-operator.
Ready for more insights from the field? I’ve made the expensive mistakes, so you don’t have to. Subscribe to get weekly strategies, real numbers, and unfiltered lessons from 25+ years of actual deals. No theory, no fluff, just lessons learned and what actually works when your money is on the line.


